< link rel="DCTERMS.isreplacedby" href="http://davejustus.com/" >

Monday, January 03, 2005

An Unlikely Pair

When you see an op-ed writen by Bill Gates and Bono you have to take a look. Actually, they make some pretty good points and have some good ideas. Here is the crux of their propossal:

For a start, we hope that the leaders of every developed nation will resolve to take four crucial steps in 2005. The wealthy world has already committed itself to some of these ideas. Promises made must be promises kept. First: double the amount of effective foreign assistance - possibly through the International Finance Facility, a UK proposal to frontload aid and get it flowing immediately. A British- and French-backed initiative using the same principles is ready to roll now and could save five million lives by increasing child immunisation. Second: finish the job on poor countries' debts. They need more than relief - they need full debt cancellation. Third: change unfair trade rules, creating a pathway for poor countries to reach self-reliance. Fourth: provide funding for the Global HIV Vaccine Enterprise, a more aggressive and coordinated approach to developing an HIV vaccine.
These are actually all things I agree with, particulary the third point. There are a variety of unfair trade rules out there, some, sadly, instigated by America. One of the best tools for poverty reduction is trade and we should do all that we can to support it.

4 Comments:

Blogger Bill said...

I agree with you and the article on making trade rules fair for all. The only way to truly enable third-world and impoverished countries to ever have a place on the world stage is allowing them to leverage those things that they can, including cheaper labor and natural resources. Current trade law, most of which serves to protect ailing "traditional" industries and labor unions, only helps keep them from the growth they so desperately need.

This article, though, disappoints me in the lack of more complete plans and details. I would like to see a lot more specific suggestions as to things that could be changed. Otherwise, it's just amount as much Vaporware as Mr. Gates has become famous for in the geek community.

1/04/2005 11:18:00 AM  
Blogger Dave Justus said...

Granted my use of the term propossal was probably a bit strong. This is largely a fluff peice with some good ideas. That being said, they were attempting to get support of a basic idea, not a specific detailed plan and I think they did a good job of that.

1/04/2005 11:45:00 AM  
Blogger Bill said...

They do mean well, I'm sure, but men of their means have to speak with actions as well as words. Perhaps I'm a bit skeptic, but after all the hype that Bill Gates gave us during the .NET launch I treat most of what he says as ideas with the goods rarely delivered.

Just the inclusion of something like "The Gates Foundation will match dollar for dollar (up to a set limit) any private donations to the World Child Immunization Project during the first three months of this year." That's action, not just talk.

Even Sandra Bullock proved that, and she's not as loaded as him.

1/04/2005 02:18:00 PM  
Blogger Dave Justus said...

I suspect that he didn't say that the "The Gates Foundation will match dollar for dollar (up to a set limit) any private donations to the World Child Immunization Project during the first three months of this year." is because he didn't want to lower the contributions he is making that much.

Here is a good blog post about have some perspective on Bill Gates, when it comes to charity at least.

1/04/2005 04:12:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home