< link rel="DCTERMS.isreplacedby" href="http://davejustus.com/" >

Friday, May 27, 2005

When Knives our outlawed, only outlaws will be chefs

The Scotsman:

LONG, pointed kitchen knives should be banned as part of a concerted effort to reduce the terrible injuries and deaths caused by stabbing attacks, doctors warned today. Accident and emergency medics claim the knives serve no useful purpose in the kitchen but are proving deadly on the streets of Britain, with the doctors claiming the knives are used in as many as half of all stabbings. The doctors claimed they had consulted leading chefs who said the knives were not needed for cooking - a claim disputed by chefs contacted by The Scotsman. Latest figures from the Scottish Executive show that in 2003, 55 of 108 homicide victims were stabbed by a sharp instrument - often a kitchen knife.
It is always interesting to see stories like this, and then here gun control advocates say with a straight face that there is no slipperly slope and the measure they are advocating will be the end of it. Sadly for Liberals, people can be nasty and brutish. We can manage to kill each other with our bare hands if need be, and some of us will do that if nothing else is availible. Humanity is not perfectable and the ingenuity of man will always find another weapon if people are denied one. Swift and certain justice for those who commit violence will do far more to reduce violence than trying to remove the ability to harm another ever will. (via Fine? Why Fine?)

3 Comments:

Blogger Patrick Lightbody said...

My thoughts:

http://www.lightbody.net/politics/archives/2005/05/gun_control_kni.html

I agree that people will always find ways to kill people. I do think that if an object has no alternative use other than killing people, we should limit its availability.

Re: deterrence -- do you think that swift and harsh punishment will stop crimes of passion ("Honey, I've been seeing someone else...")?

5/27/2005 10:59:00 AM  
Blogger Dave Justus said...

Here is a hyperlink to Patrick's post.

I don't think that killing people is always wrong. Killing to defend yourself or another is a good thing. So, tools that are made for killing people are useful tools as well. I favor having better tools, because they are a great equalizer. A 100 lb. woman with a gun is just about as dangerous as a 250 lb. man with a gun. Give them each baseball bats and the odds dramatically favor the man.

I think that deterrence does stop many crimes of passion. How many is of course hard to say, but I think human nature is universal, and when I see things like the prevalence of 'honor killing' in the Islamic world I ascribe that those killings happen in part because they are not deterred. (It is not a perfect example, because those crimes are not only not deterred, they are encouraged.) I don't thin Arabs or Muslims are more naturally inclined to kill out of a sense dishonor/passion, but I do think that the laws of a society can shape and mold that inclination.

Certainly there will always be crimes of passion. We cannot deter them all.

5/27/2005 11:10:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Superb blog. Thanks for all the information.. i learned something new from you guyz! I would like to share this to you, best chef knives directory. Complete lists of sites all about chef knives.

2/28/2008 01:29:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home